Over 97% value for your Magic the Gathering cards?

Absolutely. We're going bonkers over here, mate.

Or something like that. But yeah — for select cards, members can now get up to 97% of their card’s value*

What cards qualify?

You can check using our Magic: The Gathering Trade-In Tool. Some cards will now be flagged with “⭐ Premium Trade Inside”, and when you click on those cards, you’ll see which versions (Foil / Non-Foil / Condition) qualify for this premium rate.👇 Here's what that looks like:

Go to MTG Trade Tool

Real Example (as of Tuesday, April 15 @ 7:00PM):

At this exact moment in time, a Near Mint non-foil Sheoldred, The Apocalypse #107 is worth $71.91.

If you’re a Member, taking Store Credit, and using your Monthly Trade Boost?

🔥 You’d get $69.75 in value.That’s over 97%. Try finding a competitor even close to that. Go on. We’ll wait.

Not using a trade boost? Taking cash instead? You’re still getting excellent value:

• 💵 Cash Value: Over 48%

• 👤 Base (Non-Member): Over 60%

• 🧙‍♂️ Member (No Boost): Over 72%

This system makes our trade-in program one of the most competitive and hassle-free in the industry — fast, honest, and top-dollar.

🔝 Top Premium Trades

Want to see what cards we’re especially hunting for right now? Click the Top Premium Trades link on the tool — it’ll show you the current Top 100 premium-flagged cards we’re looking for most. It won’t show everything, but it’s a solid starting point — and it's updated daily.

* Trade-in value shown reflects the maximum possible value when a member chooses store credit and uses their monthly trade boost. No values are guaranteed. Cards may be added to or removed from Premium Trade eligibility at any time. We reserve the right to deny any trade-in for any reason. This program may change or end without notice.